Kenai Fjords or Prince William Sound?

Two glacier cruises dominate day plans from Anchorage. One sails from Seward into Kenai Fjords National Park, the other from Whittier into Prince William Sound. They look alike on a map of Alaska, yet the drive, the water and the reason to go are quite different.

Two glacier days from the same city

Most travelers with a day or two around Anchorage end up weighing the same pair of trips. A boat from Seward heads into Kenai Fjords National Park, while a cruise from Whittier threads through the inlets of Prince William Sound.

Both run in summer and both bring you to tidewater glaciers that meet the sea. What separates them is the journey to the harbor, how rough the water gets and what the day is built around.

Here we set the six Kenai Fjords boat tours we compare against the best-reviewed Sound cruise we found, the 26 Glacier Cruise by Phillips Cruises & Tours. We run neither trip, and we have no tie to either company.

The road from Anchorage

Seward is about four hours' drive from Anchorage by Major Marine's own estimate, which warns of construction and traffic on the Seward Highway. The other way down is the Alaska Railroad's Coastal Classic train, leaving Anchorage at 6:45 am and arriving at 11:15 am.

Whittier is much closer. Phillips puts the port about 1.5 hours south of Anchorage, but the last stretch runs through the Anton Anderson Memorial Tunnel, which opens to traffic at set times.

Phillips suggests leaving Anchorage by 9:00 am to make the 10:30 am tunnel opening, then arriving an hour before boarding. The self-drive version on Viator starts at 12:00 pm and lasts about five hours.

For Kenai Fjords, a morning cruise usually means a night in Seward or a very early start. Our guide to a Kenai Fjords day from Anchorage lays out the train timetable and the departures that fit it.

Tunnel toll and parking

The two Phillips listings do not agree on these costs. Viator lists the tunnel toll as included and parking of $10 to $15 as extra, while GetYourGuide names a toll of $13 and parking of $15 to $20 without saying who pays.

Ask the operator which applies to your booking before you set off. Seward has no tunnel to time, and both of its boat companies simply ask you to check in at the harbor an hour ahead.

Open sea or sheltered water

This is the biggest difference between the two days. To reach the glaciers, the Seward boats leave Resurrection Bay for open water facing the Gulf of Alaska, and the captain adjusts the route to the swell.

Major Marine's six-hour cruise chooses Holgate or Aialik Glacier on the day, depending on the weather. Kenai Fjords Tours lists its trips as not suitable for people prone to seasickness, and one reviewer of Major Marine's full day saw many passengers get sick.

Phillips describes its route through Esther Passage and College Fjord as calm water. Its Viator listing goes further with a no-seasickness guarantee, money back if you do get sick; that promise is the operator's, so read its terms before you count on it.

If motion is your main worry, the Sound looks gentler on paper. Our guide to rough seas in the Kenai Fjords explains what happens on the Seward side when the swell builds.

How much ice you see

The Whittier trip sells quantity. Phillips names it after the 26 glaciers along the route and calls the Sound one of the world's largest concentrations of tidewater glaciers, which is the company's own claim.

A Kenai Fjords day is built differently. The six-hour cruises reach one tidewater glacier, and Major Marine's 7.5-hour day at ~$319 aims for two in Aialik Bay, Aialik and Holgate, when the sea allows it.

Fewer glaciers can mean a longer look at a single ice face, with calving possible but never promised. Our guide to which boats reach the glaciers sorts all six Seward trips by the ice they reach.

An orca surfacing in front of snowy mountains in the fjords

Whales, otters and bears

Kenai Fjords is the stronger wildlife trip of the two. Its listings name humpbacks and orcas, Steller sea lions at Cape Resurrection and seabird cliffs in the Alaska Maritime National Wildlife Refuge, where puffins nest.

Phillips lists sea otters as common in the Sound, together with harbor seals and bald eagles. Orcas and humpbacks are "not uncommon" in the operator's words, and reviewers mention black bears and caribou on shore and two pods of orcas on one trip.

Neither company promises any animal. Our Kenai Fjords wildlife guide covers what the Seward listings name and when Major Marine says whale season peaks.

Side by side

Kenai Fjords (from Seward)Prince William Sound (from Whittier)
From AnchorageAbout 4 hours by road, or the morning trainAbout 1.5 hours, plus the tunnel opening times
Time on board4 to 8.5 hours, 6 hours on our pickAbout 5 hours self-drive
Tidewater glaciersOne on the 6-hour trips, two on the 7.5-hour dayA route past 26 glaciers (operator)
WaterOpen water beyond the bay, route set by the swellSheltered inlets, "calm waters" (operator)
LunchDeli sandwiches or a hot burrito, by companySmoked salmon chowder or vegetarian chili
RatingOur pick 4.9 from 2,100+ on Viator4.8 from 200+ on GetYourGuide
Price from~$287 (our pick)$260 GetYourGuide, $278 Viator

The price gap is small. Major Marine's six-hour glacier cruise at ~$287 and the Kenai Fjords Tours six-hour trip at ~$230 sit close to the Whittier fare, and our Kenai Fjords price guide lists what each one includes.

Phillips also sells an 11-hour package with a coach from Anchorage, from $368. Both sides have a bar for drinks, and Phillips lets you bring your own food but not your own alcohol.

If Seward wins the vote

Major Marine's six-hour cruise is the most reviewed Kenai Fjords trip, with one tidewater glacier, a seabird or sea lion stop chosen by the weather and a reserved seat in the heated cabin.

Who should book which

The Sound fits travelers based in Anchorage with only a day, and anyone who dreads a rolling deck. It also suits those who want to tick off as many glaciers as possible in one cruise.

  • Pick Whittier for a shorter drive and sheltered water
  • Pick Whittier if a wide sweep of glaciers matters more than wildlife
  • Pick Seward if whales and puffins rank as high as ice
  • Pick Seward if you are staying on the Kenai Peninsula anyway

Seward also offers a land glacier you can walk to, and our guide to Exit Glacier versus a boat day shows how to fit both into one stay. If the fjords win, look at our pick of the Seward glacier cruises and then compare all six Kenai Fjords cruises before you book.

Seward against Whittier

Seward or Whittier, your questions

Is Kenai Fjords or Prince William Sound better for wildlife?

Kenai Fjords listings put more weight on wildlife, naming whales, Steller sea lions and seabird cliffs with puffins. The Whittier cruise lists sea otters as common and orcas as possible. No company promises any animal.

Which cruise is calmer, Seward or Whittier?

The Whittier cruise stays in sheltered water that the operator calls calm, and its Viator listing offers a money-back seasickness guarantee. The Seward boats cross open water beyond Resurrection Bay, where the route changes with the swell.

How far is Whittier from Anchorage compared with Seward?

The operator puts Whittier about 1.5 hours from Anchorage, through a tunnel that opens at set times. Seward is about 4 hours by road, or a morning train ride on the Alaska Railroad.

Do I see more glaciers in Prince William Sound?

Yes, by the numbers. The Whittier cruise is named after 26 glaciers along its route, while a six-hour Kenai Fjords cruise reaches one tidewater glacier and the 7.5-hour day aims for two.

Is the tunnel toll included on the Whittier cruise?

The listings disagree. One lists the toll as included and parking as extra, the other names both costs without saying who pays, so ask the operator before you go.